Surrey residents risk arrest by defending historic role of juries outside Guildford Crown Court
Today a group of Surrey residents risked arrest by holding signs up outside Guildford Crown Court, demanding the right of all jurors in British courtrooms to acquit a defendant according to their conscience and irrespective of the directions of the judge.
Their action, which is part of the growing public campaign known as Defend Our Juries, saw the 12 individuals join hundreds of other concerned citizens holding these signs outside courtrooms across the UK, demanding the centuries-old principle of ‘jury equity’ - the right of a jury to decide a case according to its conscience - be protected.


Defend Our Juries was launched after 68-year retired social worker Trudi Warner, was arrested for contempt of court earlier this year, for holding a similar sign outside Inner London Crown Court in March. Then in October, two young women were arrested by the MET police for doing the same thing.
In September, the Solicitor General announced he would prosecute Trudi Warner for contempt of court. By displaying these signs, the Guildford group and other groups across the country taking part in today's action, run the risk of arrest.
Explaining why they are prepared to risk arrest for this legal principle local resident, Jackie Macey 68, a retired teacher from Dorking, said: "I am here today because I am shocked that people have been sent to prison for using the words ‘climate change’ and ‘fuel poverty’ in their defence at court.
“If you were ever to find yourself in a crown court would you not expect to be able to spend a few minutes explaining why you acted as you did? Would you as a juror want to hear that explanation in order to consider the verdict? History teaches us that when people are silenced by authority they usually have something to say that is worth listening to.”
SEE ALSO Surrey hospitals ranked some of the 'best places to work' according to regional workforce survey | Cash in suitcases conspiracy: three more people who helped smuggle £100 million of illegal cash into UK convicted
Marion Malcher, a project manager from Woking, added: “Jurors need to hear the whole truth. In fact you have to ask yourself why a judge would not want a jury to hear a defendant explain their actions.”
There are strong indications that united, collective action to defend the principle of jury equity is proving effective. Just days after the Solicitor General’s announcement to prosecute Warner, 252 people gathered outside 25 crown courts across England and Wales, holding similar signs in solidarity with Warner. None were arrested and there has been no indication of a police investigation since then. An investigation into people previously arrested for displaying posters with the same message has now been discontinued.
The Defend our Juries campaign has gathered powerful support from eminent professors of law, such as Professor Richard Vogler and Professor John Spencer.
In the words of Professor Vogler: “George Orwell noticed the tendency of repressive law to degenerate into farce, when truth becomes a lie and common sense is heresy."
"This is worth remembering now that the solicitor general, Michael Tomlinson KC, has concluded that it is right to take action against ... Trudi Warner, for holding up a sign outside a criminal court, simply proclaiming one of the fundamental principles of the common law: the right of a jury to decide a case according to its conscience.”
The demonstrations come amid mounting public concern that political trials are being turned into show trials, after a succession of jury acquittals, including the acquittal of the Colston 4 in January 2022, have embarrassed the Government and certain corporate interests.
In the Colston case, Suella Braverman, who was Attorney General at the time, decided that the jury of Bristol people had got it wrong, and brought a successful appeal to the Court of Appeal, changing the law.
Measures being taken by courts in response include defendants being banned from explaining to the jury why they did what they did, even people who have taken peaceful direct action are now being sent to prison for up to 3 years.
In some cases, people have been sent to prison just for trying to explain their actions to the jury for saying the words ‘climate change’ and ‘fuel poverty’ in court. Defendants are banned from explaining the principle of ‘jury equity’ to the jury, even though it is a well-established principle of law, which is set in marble at the original entrance to the Old Bailey.
