Caterham merger plan dropped after lukewarm public response

Plans to merge Caterham’s two parish councils into a single town council have been officially shelved after no clear public backing for the idea.

A Community Governance Review, launched last summer, has now ended with no changes, meaning Caterham on the Hill and Caterham Valley will remain separate parish councils.

Councillors agreed there was no significant support for creating a Caterham town council at a Strategy and Resources Committee meeting on January 20.

Under the proposals, Caterham would have had one parish council, with 15 councillors over five wards using current boundaries and names. Elections would have been in May 2026.

Outside units 35-41 on Croydon Road, Caterham, where a new McDonald's restaurant is proposed. (Credit: Google Street View)placeholder image
Outside units 35-41 on Croydon Road, Caterham, where a new McDonald's restaurant is proposed. (Credit: Google Street View)

Some members were frustrated. Cllr Jeremy Pursehouse called the review “a waste of time and money”, while Cllr Deano Cline described it as “a very, very sad day for Caterham”.

The review was triggered in July when both councils jointly asked Tandridge District Council to look at creating a Caterham Town Council, saying they wanted to move quickly.

Supporters argued a single council would give the town a stronger voice, especially with major local government changes on the horizon like a new East Surrey unitary authority.

What residents said

View down Station Avenue, Caterham. (Credit: Google Street View)placeholder image
View down Station Avenue, Caterham. (Credit: Google Street View)

Two public consultations were held: the first attracting 237 responses, with the second gaining just 160.

On the key question of whether the councils should merge, the opinion was split:

  • 56 per cent were in favour
  • 36 per cent were against
  • The rest were unsure

Some residents said one council made sense because Caterham is ‘one town’ and would be more efficient.

Others felt the current system works well and worried about losing local voices, rising costs and unnecessary change.

But the main issue was not enough people were interested. The review panel said the low turnout meant the results were not strong enough to justify a major shake-up, adding that the response suggested “a degree of indifference”.

Council officers defended the process, saying they had publicised the consultation widely but: “You can’t make people fill in surveys.”

Parish councils withdraw support

Crucially, both parish councils later pulled out of the process. Caterham on the Hill Parish Council said it opposed merging due to concerns over:

  • Financial risks
  • Higher admin costs
  • Loss of local knowledge
  • Possible politicisation

Caterham Valley Parish Council had backed the plan initially but withdrew after the second consultation, citing low engagement and weakening support.

Chairman Cllr Tony Pearce said: “We still believe one town council is the best way forward, but now is not the right time.”

He added they hope to revisit the idea in future.

What happens next?

The review panel unanimously agreed to keep the current arrangements. However, councillors stressed the door is not closed forever.

Cllr Robin Bloore said the parish councils could try again next year, and the outcome might be different once local government changes take effect.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice