'Characterful and unique' Surrey house saved as nine-flat plan thrown out over green belt fears
Plans to knock down a rundown house in Warlingham and replace it with a block of nine flats have been booted out.
Councillors defended the vacant and worn down home as “characterful and unique”.
Tandridge District Council’s planning committee voted to refuse the scheme for 267 Hillbury Road last night, despite council officers recommending it be approved.
Developers wanted to demolish the existing property and build a much bigger apartment block with parking and shared outdoor space.


But councillors said the new building would be far too big, out of character and would damage the Green Belt.
Cllr Keith Prew, who brought the application to committee, pulled no punches. “This is inappropriate development in the Green Belt,” he said.
“It’s massively larger than what’s there now and that will seriously harm the openness of the area.”
The Warlingham West councillor also questioned what benefit the scheme would bring.
He said: “There’s no affordable housing, so where’s the public gain? Nine houses does not constitute a significant contribution to housing needs.
Councillors were told the new building would be 240 per cent bigger in footprint and 187 per cent larger in volume than the current house.
Cllr Bryan Black said the scale of the development would “definitely impact the Green Belt”, while Cllr Fowler described it as “significantly bulkier” than the existing property.
“Each application should stand on its own,” Cllr Deborah Sherry agreed.
“This looks like overdevelopment in the green belt with no special circumstances to justify it.”
Several councillors also spoke up for the current building, which they described as quirky and full of character.
Cllr Liz Lockwood said: “It’s a very characterful and unique building.” She expressed her disappointment that the building is not a protected site as a non-designated heritage asset.
Warlingham Parish Council had strongly objected too, saying the scheme would ruin the look of the street, increase traffic and parking problems, and offer very little greenery or wildlife benefit.
Residents and campaigners from Save Warlingham’s Green Belt also weighed in, raising concerns about congestion, lack of affordable housing and the loss of a distinctive home.
Developers argued the property is currently vacant and in poor condition, and that highways officers had no issues with traffic.
But councillors were not swayed.
Cllr Martin Redman asked whether refusing the plans could land the council in trouble if the developer appeals.
But, in the end, members backed Cllr Prew’s motion to reject it.
The application was formally refused on the grounds that it would harm the Green Belt and replace a ‘characterful’ home with a bulky block of flats that does not fit the area.