Guildford councillors finally get say over £19m housing repairs report
Guildford councillors will finally get their hands on a long-awaited report into historic council housing repairs after months of frustration over being left in the dark.
The report looks at whether work ordered on council homes, from fire doors to kitchens, was actually done, and whether almost £19 million of public money was properly spent. Councillors fear it could reveal major waste or mismanagement.


“This is outrageous,” said Cllr Philip Brooker, at an Overview & Scrutiny Committee on November 18. “If we cannot access this report, we will not be forgiven by residents.”
The report has been nearly a year in the making, and councillors were alarmed when it was initially set to go straight to the Executive before they could review it. Members said this would have meant policy decisions being made without proper scrutiny.


The optics of the suggested process did not look good. The portfolio holder of housing, Julia McShane, is also the leader of the Guildford council. So the initial plans suggested the council leader and the executive would look at the extent of the mistakes made and recommend policy changes before any other elected member would have the chance to look.
At the meeting, they were assured they would now see the full report at the committee on January 20, 2026 before the Executive makes any decisions.
Cllr Brooker said he has already seen a confidential draft and produced a 27-point critique but was concerned the issues may have not been addressed.
Unlike the previous Solace report, which examined “who knew what and when” in the housing department, this new investigation dives into the actual work carried out, and what it cost the taxpayer. Essentially, it could reveal the true scale of the damage to council finances.
The investigation forms part of a wider programme that has already seen senior council officers and contractors lose their jobs. Councillors say they need to be confident that public funds were properly spent and that residents are getting value for money.
The sums involved are significant. In February 2022, the council agreed to invest £24.5 million to bring 5,200 council homes up to standard. Prior to that, a three-year deal with Seville Developments Ltd, worth £2.4 million, was agreed in 2021. Within three years, spending on the contract had ballooned to £18.9 million, a £13.5 million overspend.
Cllr Howard Smith said: “It is deeply disappointing for everyone; I think it would be wise to share the report with the regulator.”
For now, councillors and residents will have to wait until January to see the full picture. Cllr Brooker said the committee will scrutinise the findings and make recommendations, ensuring elected members, not just the Executive, have their say over how millions of pounds of public money were spent.