New homes dubbed 'uninspiring' and 'Stalin-esque' approved on Surrey car park
Plans to build 248 new homes on a Surrey car park have been given the green light despite some councillors describing the designs as “uninspiring” and “Stalin-esque”.
Guildford Borough Council’s planning committee backed the redevelopment of Guildford Park Road car park on Thursday, March 4.
The scheme paves the way for four apartment blocks and 15 townhouses just a short walk from Guildford station.
The £86m project will transform the existing surface car park into a new residential neighbourhood, delivering 248 homes in total.


The scheme includes 99 affordable homes, made up of 65 for affordable rent and 34 shared ownership properties.
Councillors broadly agreed the town needed the homes, although several raised concerns about the design of the development.
Cllr Patrick Oven criticised the appearance, comparing it to “Stalin-esque 1950s architecture”, although he added: “It’s not that bad but I think a little bit of imagination could have made it better.”
Council officers recommended the scheme for approval, saying it would significantly boost housing supply at a time when the authority cannot demonstrate a five-year housing land supply.
The site, next to the railway line and close to the University of Surrey, will include new landscaping, a children’s play area, cycle parking and improved pedestrian routes.
Buses, cyclists and pedestrians will still be able to travel through the site to the university.
‘Uninspiring at best’
Cllr Stephen Hives compared the design to Eastern European housing blocks but said that was not grounds for refusal.
“For me they look more like the comunale you find on the outskirts of Odessa,” he said.
Cllr Hives complained that members often hear they need to “Guildford’s identity” but then the council seems to “flip flop” as to what the identity is.
Cllr Joss Bigmore agreed, saying: “Guildford is very eclectic in its character. [The problem is] we don’t have a defining [style]. We have some wonderful historic areas and we have some newbuild bits.”
He warned the town risked ending up with piecemeal development unless clearer design principles were introduced.
Cllr Bigmore described the proposals as underwhelming for such a prominent gateway site.
“It’s dull and uninspiring at best,” he said.
Housing mix
Cllr Howard Smith said the scheme would provide much-needed housing in a sustainable location.
He said: “I’m sold on this and would vote for it every day of the week.”
However, Cllr Smith questioned the level of shared ownership housing in the plans, asking what evidence there was for demand and suggesting more homes should be provided for social or affordable rent.
Planning officers said the mix reflected evidence from a 2015 housing needs assessment that underpins the borough’s Local Plan, with further work already under way on an updated assessment for the next plan.
Despite those concerns, councillors ultimately agreed there were no planning grounds to refuse the scheme.
Construction is expected to start in summer 2026, with the development due to be completed by the end of 2028.