Plans for 270 homes in Surrey approved after inspector concludes nearby town is actually a village
Plans for up to 270 homes can now go ahead after an appeal where the inspector found the nearby settlement was a village, and not, as the local authority claimed, a “large built up area” or town.
Councillors threw out the Chapel Road scheme at a planning committee in May 2024 arguing it would be an inappropriate development in the green belt around Smallfield.


Tandridge District Council’s case was that the land contributed strongly to stopping the “unrestricted sprawl of large built-up areas” like towns and cities.
But the planning inspector David Prentis concluded Smallfield is ‘village” and the 15-hectare site on Chapel Road is actually grey belt.


This means the land is poor quality and does not contribute to preventing ‘urban sprawl’ or conserving the countryside.
Although Prentis found the proposal would have a “major adverse effect on the landscape character of the site itself”, he said the visual impact would be “localised” because of the site’s “visual containment”.
He judged the adverse effects on the green belt and countryside would not outweigh the significant housing benefits provided by the scheme.
Approximate 49 per cent of the homes (132) would be affordable, according to the appeal report – split into 75 per cent affordable rent/social rent and 25 per cent shared ownership.
Only an outline application full details of the scale, mass and sort of homes are yet to be revealed.
Illustrative proposals suggest the high density apartment buildings will be at the centre of the site with different size houses expanding outwards.
The developers also agreed to make land available for the relocation of Burstow Primary School, create green spaces, provide off-site highway works and flood relief works, the report said.
Changes to national planning rules in December 2024 also impacted the case.
The concept of ‘grey belt’ was introduced as poor quality or ugly areas where development is less restricted.
Planning inspector Prentis concluded the land could be considered ‘grey belt’, as developing it would not undermine the area’s remaining green belt and would help to improve the district’s housing land supply of only 1.92 years.
In the 2023 published housing delivery test, Tandridge Council was found to be providing only 42 per cent of the housing requirement.