Plans for 74 new homes near Surrey garden centre despite traffic conerns
A major development has been approved despite fears it will cause “severe” talibacks and gridlock a town – and has left the future of a garden centre in doubt.
Plans for 74 homes at Clifton Nurseries Garden Centre in Woburn Hill, Addlestone, were green lit. While the garden centre is currently operating as normal, it would be demolished to make way for the mix of two storey houses and maisonettes.
The plans were approved despite pushback from residents and councillors who argued the location was too near the already congested A317 trunk roads that serve Addlestone, Chertsey and Weybridge as well as the M25 near Heathrow.
One resident who wrote in opposing the plans said: “When the level crossing is down in Station Road, Addlestone (at least twice per hour), the traffic congestion is severe along both the A317 and Station Road.”
The report presented to the meeting said that it acknowledged “concerns raised by residents in terms of increased traffic as a result of the proposed development” and that “the development will result in an increase to vehicle traffic”. However, it added “this would not lead to a severe impact on the surrounding highway network.”
Refusing the plans would have left Runnymede Borough Council open to legal challenges from developers, they claimed. The traffic concerns were dismissed by Surrey Highways as being a non-issue, its planning committee heard.
Councillor Silvia White, who chairs the council’s planning committee, said: “There was nowhere to go with it, but I do understand residents’ frustrations. It’s a very busy road, but, from the officers report, the car journey won’t be much higher than if it was left as a garden nursery.
“As a planning authority we have to rely on Survey to give its thoughts, and highways said it was ok, so if we refused the developers would have just taken us to court and won. We can only judge on planning grounds and there was nothing that we could refuse it for
.”The approved 74 homes is a scaled down version of the original proposals – which were for 90 units in the form of 48 flats (in 3 storey blocks) and 42 houses.
The plans were amended due to green belt concerns and will now feature of a mix of two storey houses and maisonettes – with the precise level of affordable housing is still being negotiated.
The council has given a broad figure of between 35 per cent to 80 per cent” of the homes will be listed as affordable.
Cllr Peter Snow, leader of the Conservative opposition group as well as a planning committee member, knows the area particularly well having been elected to represent Addlestone South since 2018.
He argued that there was scope in the council’s planning bible – the local plan – to refuse the development. The document – which forms the basis of where and the types of development should be permitted in the borough – has been signed off by planning inspectors.
It specifies that the council has “a number of existing transport and infrastructure issues within the borough and beyond including” and that there are ‘congestion hotspots’ including the M25 and A317 – precisely where this development will impact.
He said: “Looking at that page – it clearly states that the only way we can look at more development in that area was improving infrastructure.
“You can’t argue with the scheme but it is becoming a real pain .“I walk Addlestone every night and see traffic along the high street.“There’s been a steady increase. It used to be a mile from St Peter’s now it’s about two miles and when the level crossing at Addlestone is down it’s just chaos.”