Plans to replace former library in Merstham rejected

Fears of fans of a popular community football club and users of an Age Concern centre would suffer has meant plans to turn the derelict former Merstham Library into 11 shared occupancy homes have been thrown out.

Reigate and Banstead Borough Council’s planning committee met to discuss transforming the abandoned building into “much needed” housing but the proposals were roundly rejected over the impact it would have on a shared access road off Weldon Way.

The site is used by Merstham Football and Social Club predominantly during the evenings and weekends with Age Concern using it for drop offs and collections. The access road is also used as the emergency evacuation point for elderly people.

The planning committee heard that using the road for the proposed homes would have had too great an impact on the existing users and could lead to potential strife with the new owners.

The former Merstham library site (Image Google)placeholder image
The former Merstham library site (Image Google)

Addressing the meeting was Councillor Michael Blacker (Con, Reigate). He said: “I am much in favour of the proposed shared ownership houses especially as they are a much needed form of social housing in our borough. However they can not be built to the total detriment of three sets of residents and potentially a fourth set.

“We were all expecting (developers) Raven to use one or both of the existing dropped kerb accessed directly off Weldon Way. Had they done so I would not be making these comments today.

“The first group to be affected are Merstham Football Club, after the loss of two local pubs, the Iron Horse and more particularly The Limes, the football clubhouse has become Merstham residents’ local pub.

“The access road is the club’s lifeline.” He said the road was used for deliveries, parking, and pedestrian access – with the all the surrounding roads fully parked on match days.

The clubhouse, he said, was regularly full as a social centre. He added: “Parking and clear access is at a premium.

The second group impacted, the meeting heard, was Age Concern which has more than 130 members, staff and volunteers who visit the site each week, and “it’s growing by 10 per cent a year”.

Cllr Blacker said: “They also require the access drive to evacuate elderly members should there be an emergency.

“There is also an assembly point in case of fire, just where the access road is proposed. With an ageing population access is even more important.”

The site is currently occupied by the former single storey brick library building. It closed in 2017 when the branch was relocated to the Merstham Community Hub.

The freehold was purchased by Raven Housing Trust in March 2021. The proposed site is surrounded by the Moat House Surgery, a day centre and community hall and the Merstham Recreation Ground.

The new homes would have have been in two pairs of semi-detached two storey buildings and two terrace rows, one with three dwellings and one with four dwellings.

The housing mix would have been four two-bed (four-person houses) and seven three-bed (five-person houses). All the properties would have been classified as affordable.

The planning application had deferred been from March to consider recommendations for refusal although officers still supported the plan.

Cllr Blacker added: “The third group are the local residents. The neighbouring roads were built when car ownership was few and far and now the opposite is true with most houses having at least one car and many having more.

“Parking is at a premium and the loss of parking on the access road will impact them.”

Incoming residents of the new proposed shared ownership, he added, would immediately run into conflict with the three other groups.

Cllr Shasha Khan (Green, Hooley, Merstham and Netherne) said: “We must consider all residents here most of all our elderly who require the access to Age Concern.”

Councillors rejected the plans by 12 votes to one, on the grounds that its layout, dominance and shared access would result in a cramped over development that was harmful to the community.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice