Surrey campaigners warn of flooding as luxury retirement village goes to appeal
A decision to reject plans for a retirement village on a former Surrey landfill has been appealed despite locals saying the homes would be “wasted”.
The scheme for luxury senior living accommodation was proposed for land near Vicarage Road, in Sunbury, but was refused by Spelthorne Borough Council (SBC) in October 2023.


The authority rejected the application as it would be built on the Green Belt, be out of character with the rural area and not contribute to affordable homes for Surrey residents.
The first phase of the application included a village centre and 66 homes. The second phase would include a further 98 extra care homes and a 60-bed care home.


Proposed on Green Belt land, the scheme was rejected by SBC as it was judged as an “inappropriate development”. Although the Green Belt is designed to stop urban sprawl, the proposal would be built on one of the last slithers of land separating Surrey from London.
“If this goes against us I’m going to lose all hope,” said Councillor Harry Boparai (Liberal Democrat/ Sunbury Common), who spoke at the start of the appeal. “This isn’t for Spelthorne people, it’s so developers can line their pockets.”
Although a flood risk was not one of the reasons officially given when SBC rejected the application, Cllr Boparai said safety is his primary concern. Campaigners and Cllr Boparai argue the area has been extremely vulnerable to flooding for decades, ever since the Beechwood estate expanded in 1987. The site, comprising 5.6 hectares of ‘permeable’ land, could exacerbate the floods as the rainwater has limited places to run off.
“We have awful flooding in the surrounding areas,” said Hazel Osborn, a resident fighting against the application. “Our children have to walk through dirty puddles to get to and from school after heavy rain [and] the playground often gets flooded.”
She told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS), how her children have to wade through puddles to get to school due to the heavy rain at the end of September. Due to the downpours of rain, standing water was left in the middle of the road creating a river down the street. The primary school is just a 10 minute walk from the proposed development site.
But independent assessments from the developer claim that most of the site is low flood risk with only the southern boundary as ‘medium’ flood risk. The Environment Agency (EA) also raised no official objections to the application on flooding grounds.
Contaminated material has been found underneath the top layer of land on the former gravel extraction site, according to council documents. The EA has also expressed concerns the development would disturb historic landfill, causing illegal waste activity.
‘Not for Spelthorne people’
Cllr Boparai expressed his frustration that despite democratic processes being followed, every Spelthorne councillor voting against the proposal, the developer has still taken it to appeal. He said: “I’m very close to telling people to stop paying their council tax, as they are just being ignored.”
He said: “Sunbury health care is bursting and [this development] is shipping elderly residents from other areas.” With only one GP surgery in Sunbury, and no dentists, both locals and councillors fear the development will put extra pressure on already strained services.
Plans for the retirement village split opinion in 2023: over 200 letters were sent by those supporting the application, and 200 opposing the development. Residents speaking in favour of the proposal said retirement and care homes for the elderly are needed and will “free up family homes”. Some said that the proposal would create jobs, and that the green belt land being built on is of low value and not being used effectively. But councillors also noted at the time that many letters of support were received after the deadline and not all were from the area closest to the development.
‘Wasted here’
Campaigners against the proposal have argued Spelthorne needs affordable housing for all and improved infrastructure, not bespoke senior living accommodation. “The fees are extortionate,” Hazel said. “Neither my family or anyone I know could afford the price of living there.”
A ground floor two-bedroom apartment at a potentially equivalent Hampshire site could set you back £659,000 according to the company’s website. A ‘village centre’ one-bedroom apartment at a Bedfordshire site costs £363,000 excluding service charges, leasehold and event fees.
“People presume it is well-needed care homes, but this development is far from that, said Hazel, who lives in Sunbury. “I’m not against development, we desperately need housing and elderly care, but again, Inspired Villages would be wasted here in my opinion. We need affordable housing for all and improved infrastructure, not a luxury retirement home.”
Opened on September 18, the appeal is due to last eight weeks. Flooding implications and concluding arguments will be heard on November 4.
Ellen Pearce, Head of Planning for Inspired Villages, attended the appeal on its behalf: “Inspired Villages operates nine Integrated Retirement Communities with two further villages opening this year, supporting over 1,400 residents. Our experience and track record has proven time and again that the facilities and benefits of our established villages not only positively impact the residents and colleagues who work there, but also wider communities.
“In addition to these benefits, this proposal will contribute to meeting the growing need for specialist housing for older people in Spelthorne, through the delivery of an Integrated Retirement Community and a Care Home. The addition of an on-site medical facility to be offered to the NHS further negates concerns raised on the provision of care for residents. We believe Very Special Circumstances have been demonstrated within our proposals, and hope that the Government-appointed Planning Inspector recognises the benefits of the development and the need it is fulfilling.”
Officer’s report 2023: https://publicaccess.spelthorne.gov.uk/online-applications/files/643DA873D42C8250FE7B554AF5FCD944/pdf/23_00121_OUT-COMMITTEE_REPORT-734697.pdf
Flood risk assessment: https://publicaccess.spelthorne.gov.uk/online-applications/files/49C1307DA86851687185DBF9E5790047/pdf/23_00121_OUT-FLOOD_RISK_ASSESSMENT-710848.pdf
Appeal documents: https://publicaccess.spelthorne.gov.uk/online-applications/applicationDetails.do?activeTab=documents&keyVal=RPCITHPB0EG00