Tighter controls loom on shared houses as residents complain HMOs have 'descended' on Surrey village

Tandridge District Council is moving to tighten planning controls after a surge in family homes being converted into shared houses across Whyteleafe and Caterham.

Councillors have agreed to start the legal process to introduce an immediate Article 4 Direction, which would force landlords to apply for planning permission before turning houses into small HMOs (homes in multiple occupation) for up to six people.

The decision follows a sharp rise in HMO conversions, mounting complaints from residents and fears that entire streets are losing family homes.

Residents raise alarm

View down Station Avenue, Caterham. (Credit: Google Street View)placeholder image
View down Station Avenue, Caterham. (Credit: Google Street View)

At a Planning Policy Committee meeting on January 15, a resident told councillors that developers have “descended on Whyteleafe” since 2022, with the pace of conversions accelerating dramatically over the past year.

She accused some landlords of being “economical with the truth” to bypass planning rules and questioned why the council had not acted sooner.

“I’m a leaseholder with the council. If I want to move my kitchen tap to the other side of the room, I need permission,” they said.

“Meanwhile, is being turned from a three-bedroom house into a six-bedroom property, with extensions added, and there’s been no scrutiny.”

‘We were slow off the mark’

Leader of Tandridge council, and also chairing the meeting, Cllr Catherine Sayer admitted the situation had worsened significantly in Whyteleafe and Caterham

She said the HMO increase was driven partly by people moving out of London.

“A lot of Article 4 directions were introduced in Croydon and Sutton,” she said.

“I wasn’t aware this had been such a long-standing problem here. I apologise for being slow off the mark.”

Cllr Martin Redman said Westway (in Caterham) saw almost a five-fold increase in HMOs last year, blaming developers for abusing permitted development rules.

He warned family homes were being lost at an alarming rate, although he acknowledged HMOs provide essential accommodation for groups such as care workers and people facing major life changes.

Cllr Keith Prew said the proposals were too limited and criticised the exclusion of Warlingham from the scheme.

“It borders Whyteleafe and Caterham and is close to the station,” he said. “If we don’t have an HMO problem today, we will tomorrow.”

Council officers said measures like Article 4 need a lot of evidence to back up the new rules.

Warlingham does not yet show a high enough concentration of HMOs but agreed to keep the area under review.

What the data shows

Council figures reveal:

  • 13 HMOs were licensed in 2025 alone, compared with just four the previous year
  • 53 per cent of all HMOs in the district are now in Whyteleafe and Caterham
  • Complaints jumped from zero in 2018 to 31 in 2025
  • Most complaints relate to parking, noise, poor housing conditions and anti-social behaviour

A council report said evidence form officers, councillors and site visits show an overconcentration of HMOs, leading to parking stress, poor housing conditions, anti-social behaviour, drainage issues and erosion of local character.

Officers said site visits uncovered sub-standard accommodation, drainage problems and poorly maintained land.

What happens next

The council will now launch a public consultation and carry out statutory notices.

A final decision on whether to confirm the Article 4 Direction will return to councillors after feedback is reviewed.

If approved, all new HMO conversions in Whyteleafe and Caterham will require planning permission but existing HMOs will not be affected.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice