The Hornets – who were making their first appearance in the second round proper since 2007 after first round opponents Barnsley were expelled from the competition due to an ‘administrative error’ – went toe-to-toe with the U’s in the first half but second half goals from Dion Pereira (2) and Omari Patrick saw the hosts book a place in the third round.
But who stood out for Horsham at Gander Green Lane? Here’s how Sam Pole viewed the Hornets’ performances.
13. Lucas Rodrigues
Rodrigues came on midway through the second half and brought a much needed energy to the Hornets after they had just conceded. He was tenacious in the tackle and fought for every loose ball and 50-50 to try and help Horsham get back into the match. Photo: John Lines
14. Kadell Daniel
Daniel came on late in the second half and looked lively but ultimately could not bring the Hornets back into the tie. Photo: Getty Images
15. Tom Richards
Richards came on as a substitute late in the second half. The winger looked to provide a spark on the left to try and get Horsham back in the game. Unfortunately he couldn't recreate his moment of magic against Barnsley in the second round tie. Photo: John Lines
16. Jack Mazzone
Mazzone came on late in the second half to try and create another attacking threat for the Hornets in the final ten minutes. Unfortunately the striker couldn't create any clear cut chances during his limited time on the pitch. Photo: John Lines